Improving Software Testing Efficiency: How Test Analytics and Prioritization Work Together for Better Quality

Introduction

Test Analytics and Test Prioritization are integral components of modern software testing methodologies. They enable organizations to streamline their testing processes, allocate resources efficiently, and deliver higher-quality software products. By leveraging data-driven insights and strategic prioritization, teams can find their way through the complex challenge of balancing testing and time-to-market pressures, ultimately delivering software that meets user expectations and stands up to real-world challenges.

In this article, we’ll talk about how test case prioritization and test analytics work together to achieve comprehensive testing while ensuring efficient resource allocation. Whether you’re a quality assurance expert or a software developer, learning these techniques can help you deliver robust, high-quality software in an ever-evolving digital landscape.

Understanding Test Analytics

Test Analytics involves the collection, interpretation, and utilization of data generated during the testing process. By utilizing data-driven insights, organizations can gain a deeper understanding of their testing efforts. This understanding extends beyond merely counting bugs or test cases executed. Test Analytics delves into patterns, trends, and performance metrics, empowering teams to make informed decisions about their testing strategies.

The key aspects and activities related to test analytics are as below:

• Data Collection: Test analytics starts with the collection of relevant data from various sources. This data can include test case results, defect reports, test execution times, code coverage metrics, and more. Test management tools and test automation frameworks often generate this data.
• Data Analysis: Once the data is collected, it needs to be analyzed to extract meaningful insights. Data analysis can involve various techniques such as statistical analysis, trend analysis, and visualization to identify patterns, anomalies, and potential areas of concern.
• KPIs (Key Performance Indicators): Test analytics often involves tracking and measuring key performance indicators related to testing. Common KPIs in test analytics include test pass rates, test coverage, defect density, and mean time to detect and fix defects.
• Defect Tracking: Analysing defect data is a crucial part of test analytics. This involves tracking the number of defects found, their severity, their status (open, closed, in progress), and the time it takes to resolve them. This information helps prioritize bug fixes and assess the quality of the software.
• Test Progress and Test Case Execution: Test analytics can also provide insights into the progress of testing efforts. It can track the execution status of test cases, identifying which test cases have been executed, passed, failed, or are pending execution.
• Test Efficiency and Resource Allocation: Test analytics can help assess the efficiency of testing efforts by analyzing how resources (e.g., testers, environments, automation tools) are utilized. This information can be used to optimize resource allocation and improve testing productivity.
• Continuous Improvement: Test analytics should support a culture of continuous improvement in the testing process. By analyzing historical data and identifying areas for improvement, teams can make data-driven decisions to enhance their testing practices.
• Predictive Analytics: In some advanced cases, predictive analytics may be used to forecast potential issues or defects based on historical data. Machine learning models can be trained to identify patterns that may lead to future problems.

Platforms such as LamdaTest already have a very extensive Test Analytics Dashboard that can be leveraged for test case prioritization.

Need for Test Case Prioritization

Test Prioritization focuses on optimizing the sequence in which tests are executed based on their importance, impact, and potential risk. As it is practically impossible to exhaustively test every aspect of a complex software system, test prioritization helps allocate testing resources wisely.

By identifying critical areas, high-priority features, and areas susceptible to defects, teams can ensure that testing efforts are focused where they matter most, thus, achieving comprehensive coverage even within resource constraints. Prioritizing test maintenance efforts to ensure the most relevant test cases are maintained and kept running always. Early bug detection and remediation by executing tests that check parts of the application that are prone to failure.

Test Analytics Parameters Aiding Test Prioritization

The following parameters of test analytics are key to the prioritization of test cases:

• Defect Density

Defect density is numerical data that determines the number of defects detected in software or components during a specific development period. You can use this formula to calculate the defect density:

Defect Density = Total Defect/Size

The higher the density of defects in a specific component more is the probability of the component being error prone. Hence, test cases of such components need to be prioritized to ensure the stability of the application.

• Frequency of Change

Application components that are prone to change frequently carry an inherent risk of breaking often. A key to de-risking such changes is to tighten the testing around these areas of the application by prioritizing the test design and execution of these components.

• Test Flakiness Index

Flaky tests are defined as tests that return both passes and failures despite no changes to the code or the test itself. The Test Flakiness Index can be calculated based on the below formula:

Test Flakiness Index = No of failed runs / Total number of runs

A threshold is defined for this metric and when the value goes below this threshold parameter the tests are automatically flagged as being flaky. These flaky tests are then removed from the daily automated run and the team prioritizes the effort required to fix these flaky tests before reintroducing them to the automation suite.

• Slowest Test

The Slowest Test is a measure of the tests that are taking too long to run. In today’s enterprise software ecosystem, these tests drain the system resources. In terms of priority, the tests that are identified as slowest need to be decoupled from the continuous testing suite temporarily and need to be replaced with much more nimbler and faster checks.

• Never Run Test

This is a key measure of tests that are never executed in our Continuous Testing Pipeline; these are tests that add no value as they haven’t ever been executed before. They are good candidates to be removed from the execution pipeline.

• Failure Analysis

Failure Analysis on defects logged based on the execution of test cases can help to prioritize the type of test cases that need to be executed for the specific component in future builds. The failure reasons can be grouped as Product, Regression, Functional, Negative, and Edge. The test cases that test these specific reasons are prioritized so as to ensure that future builds are tested comprehensively for behaviors that have caused the application to break earlier.

Benefits of Prioritization

Prioritizing test cases in software testing can offer numerous benefits that significantly enhance the testing process and overall software quality. Here are some key advantages:

• Improved Defect Detection: Prioritizing test cases ensures that high-priority test cases are executed early in the testing cycle. This increases the likelihood of detecting critical defects sooner, allowing for faster bug fixes.
• Reduced Time and Cost: By executing high-priority test cases first, you can quickly identify and address critical issues. This reduces the overall testing time and associated costs, as fewer resources are spent on lower-priority test cases.
• Enhanced Test Coverage: Test case prioritization ensures that critical functionalities and scenarios are thoroughly tested before lower-priority ones. This approach can improve overall test coverage, even if some lower-priority tests are skipped or delayed.
• Faster Feedback: High-priority test cases provide quick feedback on the most important aspects of the software. This allows developers to address critical issues early in the development cycle, leading to faster and more efficient development iterations.
• Risk Mitigation: Prioritization helps in managing project risks effectively. By addressing the testing of high-risk areas first, you reduce the likelihood of major issues emerging late in the development process, which can be costly and time-consuming to fix.
• Test Capacity Allocation: It helps in allocating testing capacity more efficiently. Testers can focus on the most critical test cases, ensuring that their efforts are directed toward areas of the application that matter the most.
• Customer Satisfaction: By identifying and fixing critical defects early, you improve the overall quality of the software. This, in turn, leads to higher customer satisfaction and trust in the product.
• Efficient Regression Testing: Test case prioritization is especially valuable for regression testing. By prioritizing test cases based on the areas most affected by recent changes, you can focus regression efforts on the most critical parts of the application.

Test Case Prioritization is a continuous activity that needs to either happen automatically based on the test analytics parameters or at a specific time that needs to be set aside within the sprint for the team to do this activity manually. The ideal approach for automated tests is to get this prioritization also done automatically based on the signals we intercept from the test analytics data.

Conclusion

In conclusion, combining test analytics with test case prioritization is a strong strategy for improving software testing efficiency and effectiveness. In today’s fast-paced and complex software development landscape, using data to decide which tests to focus on is not just an option but a necessity. When organizations implement test case prioritization informed by test analytics, they can gain several valuable advantages. These include the ability to identify and address high-risk areas early in the development process, optimize testing capacity and time, speed up product release, and ultimately deliver higher-quality software to their users.

However, it’s crucial to recognize that successful implementation of test analytics and test case prioritization demands a strategic and well-planned approach. Teams must carefully choose the right tools, establish clear testing objectives, and continuously adapt their testing strategies to accommodate changes in their applications and user requirements.

Ashok Kumar

Engineering Leader responsible for quality within agile teams, QA delivery, innovation, and value Quality evangelist and test architect focused on shifting left quality. Coached teams on the agile way of working and the significance of quality becoming a team responsibility. Successfully Delivered & Executed Quality Engineering Programs for major Fortune 100 Clients. Built high-performing teams and coached them on a culture of quality.

See author's profile